As children of God, we love the truth. It set us free, and now we see how lies and self deception chain others to the very things we have been liberated from. We want them to experience the glorious freedom that comes from walking in the truth.
But sometimes in our zeal, we can become so consumed with telling people the truth that we forget the person standing in front of us. I don’t know, maybe it’s easier to identify what is wrong with someone than to consider what they actually need. We can become so focused on sound theology and truth that we lose sight of everything else.
Yes, truth and sound theology should be central.
But also, love.
Yeah, yeah. Truth and love. We know all about that. Heard it a million times.
Well, let’s still examine it more closely and start with the character of God. Or rather, let’s imagine two incomplete pictures of God and consider the danger of separating truth from love.
A God Who Is Only Truth
I try to imagine a god who is only truth with no love. Before that god, I see myself cowering in overwhelming guilt. Before him, I see the glaring realities of my sin, with nowhere to hide and no hope, only the terrible truth of what I am. What would it be to stand before a god who knows all but offers no tenderness, no compassion, no love?
A God Who Is Only “Love”
I try to imagine a god who is only “love” with no truth. He is a candy man. Before such a god, I am left wandering, without purpose, swallowed up in the misery of my own selfishness. What would it be to stand before a god who assures me I am “loved” but leaves me a prisoner to all my wants that are destroying me?
Some time ago, I was deeply wronged and hurt by someone. A friend heard about it from the source and called me. Before I answered the call, I hesitated. I have been the recipient of many different people hitting me over the head with control and manipulation through the years, especially in my lowest moments. I was so raw, I thought, I am in no place to be talked down to or to be told how I should be feeling right now.
But I answered the call.
This friend began the conversation by saying they didn’t have much to say; they just wanted to listen. I briefly, hesitatingly shared a few sentences. Their response? The most compassionate words in the kindest tone I think I’ve ever heard in my life: “I’m sure you’re angry.” I muted the phone and cried. That’s about all I remember. Words cannot describe the healing that washed over me. Forgiveness came much sooner because of it.
That person will always have an open door to speak into my life, and they have, a lot! Why? Because they listened first and showed they cared about me. What they said was so simple, but it was strangely what I needed to hear in that moment, and their words weren’t just to make them feel good about themselves.
I’ve also had times when people who love me have said hard truths to me. While those conversations may have stung in the moment, they were fruitful because those friends took the time to understand and gave thoughtful, careful responses.
I could give plenty of negative examples, far more than positive ones, of people who were certain they “knew” things. Their opinions came without asking questions, verifying anything, or considering that they might not have the whole story, or even the right one. Some of the most chilling body language and scathing rebukes I’ve ever received came from people who knew nothing of what they were talking about. It was so ridiculous that, looking back, I have to laugh, even though they really wrecked me at the time.
“But Breanna, if we acknowledge people’s pain, anger or sadness, then they will have a victim mentality, we don’t want to start that!”
What a heartbreaking small view of grace that is.
Of course people can develop unhealthy patterns of coping and thinking, and I know plenty — Facebook is full of it, too. But if we get to that bridge, we can cross it when we get there. Someone’s theoretically possible response to our compassion should not govern how we treat them now.
That said, being hurt doesn’t give us license to share our hurts indiscriminately either. Our pain may be real, but we still need wisdom in how and where we speak about it.
So how do we learn to hold truth and love together, where do we go to find the real thing?
JESUS.
He embodied perfect truth and perfect love. He reclined and ate with sinners, touched the most afflicted bodies, and entered the messiest situations. He showed the deepest compassion and spoke the frankest truths.
“A bruised reed he will not break, and a faintly burning wick he will not quench.” —Isaiah 42:3
Ah, but don’t forget, Jesus called out the Pharisees and called them whitewashed tombs, blind fools, and a brood of vipers. He spoke truth more than just frankly; He wielded it like a blade.
Yes. Yes, He did. He exposed their hypocrisy and pride, their pretense of moral superiority, their neglect of justice and mercy, and the burdens they had no right to impose on others. They were using the law to feel fabulous about themselves, not out of genuine care for people’s souls.
I wonder why we are so quick to point to Jesus’ most piercing words to justify our own severity, yet so slow to consider whether His rebukes might also apply to us?
How easy it is, when someone shares something painful with us, to rush in with what we think they should hear, or what we want to say to feel more spiritual about ourselves. It says so much if the first thing off our tongue is, “I don’t think they meant to hurt you,” or we jump straight to the good old classic, “And would you be open to reconciliation?” All before we’ve taken a moment to acknowledge their pain, understand what happened, or even wonder whether they’ve already sought “reconciliation.” We form conclusions before we even know what they’ve already done. I wonder if we mirror the religious Pharisees in more ways than we realize. They, too, loved being recognized as teachers and treated as the ones with all the answers.
What about the matter of outright sin in Christians who should know better? Let’s look at the Biblical instructions for this:
“Brothers, if anyone is caught in any transgression, you who are spiritual should restore him in a spirit of gentleness. Keep watch on yourself, lest you too be tempted. —Galatians 6:1
A “spirit” of gentleness. That’s interesting because it speaks to more than the tone or words we choose. We can deliver a firm correction with a gentle heart, just as we can speak in a calm voice while harboring deep contempt. I think that’s one reason Paul tells us to watch ourselves: the person being restored is not the only one at risk of sinning.
Of course, gentleness doesn’t guarantee that someone will receive the truth. Just because someone rejects what we say doesn’t mean we did it all wrong. Sometimes people really don’t want or care about the truth, no matter how much love, care, and grace we give.
Truth is precious to me in ways I can’t fully explain here. It has cost me much, but given me much too. I’m naturally blunt, but God has used hard things to make me more sensitive to the pain of others. I no longer feel the need to speak my mind at every opportunity, and I’m learning we can stand for truth and still get it very wrong if we step over hurting people to do it.
We could all stand on a street corner and yell the truth out to the masses, if only that’s all it took. Actually, writing that brings old memories to mind. Been there, been a part of all that in my good old ‘street preaching’ days with Charity folks. A tear just came to my eye, but it’s a laughing tear, unfortunately, because the irony of it all is hitting a funny bone. I think about how some hollered while we all sang and passed out very cheesy tracts at the Iowa City mall every summer. All the while we believed that unless those women out there would wear very long homemade plain colored triple layered dresses and the men would promise to not wear t-shirts, they could not be part of our church. How eager we were to tell people what needed to change. But I’m not so sure we would have been as eager to love them as they learned to follow Christ.
Street preaching. Good or bad? I know not. The bigger question to me is, are we willing to walk with people? Are we willing to show compassion to the hurting, to make a meal and eat with them? Will we say: I’m sorry for your pain, let’s find the next right step together. Let’s find Jesus, who meets us here in our brokenness with love and whose truth brings us full and complete freedom.
That’s the Gospel and discipleship. It’s also just being a good friend. We ourselves were blind, hostile to righteousness, dead in our sin. But God so loved the world that He sent us Jesus who is the way, the truth, and the life. And at the cross, Jesus did not set aside the truth about our sin, but His saving love made a way for us to be changed and reconciled to Him. This is the Gospel we have been given to carry to others.
“For from his fullness we have all received, grace upon grace. For the law was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ.” —John 1:16-17
May we never be so eager to speak the truth that we forget the love and mercy by which we came to know it.